13 Comments

New to (proper) home bartending. Might have not been quite as precise as I needed to be, but the first attempt at this came out quite sweet. Could be that my limes were not the greatest. I tried with slightly less syrup and it was quite a bit better, st least for my taste.

The salt is interesting. I did one with and one without and it is pretty amazing that a few drops really helps pull everything together.

Expand full comment

The salt makes a giant difference!

If you find it too sweet, you can try cutting the sugar like you did, or switching to a 1:1 sugar:water simple syrup. (Make it the same way — blend equal parts by weight sugar and water, then store chilled.) The 1:1 syrup will change the texture a bit but might get you closer to the profile you’re looking for.

Expand full comment

Yeah, I tried it again this afternoon with 1:1 and much prefer it. Still well balanced, but I like that the bite of the lime juice cuts through

Expand full comment

I've found quite a bit of variation in my limes, but some of them have definitely been a bit "aged" unintentionally in the fridge and rather firm.

Expand full comment

A few weeks ago, I had a craving for daiquiris and I only had Bacardi Superior. I didn't quite like the daiquiri I made with it in the past. So, I did 1.75 oz Bacardi and 1/4 oz of Hamilton 151 and it was great. I'll tweak that some more based on this post

Expand full comment

A few weeks ago, I had a craving for daiquiris and I only had Bacardi Superior. I didn't quite like the daiquiri I made with it in the past. So, I did 1.75 oz Bacardi and 1/4 oz of Hamilton 151 and it was great. I'll tweak that some more based on this post

Expand full comment

For science (I wasn't reading the recipe closely) I made this daiquiri using rich demerara syrup because that's the sweetener used in the Smuggler's Cove recipe. On one hand, the results are a lot less photogenic than a daiquiri made using rich simple syrup. On the other hand, it's always fun to see how much you can change a drink with a slight change to the ratio. Adding slightly more of both lime and demerara results in a drink that's less sweet and more citrus-y than the SC daiquiri since the overall ratio of lime to everything else is higher.

A bit of salt should definitely be the secret ingredient to more lime-based cocktails. It's great in a mai tai, for example. I guess I'll have to try it in a gimlet now.

Expand full comment

Oh yeah! This sounds great. Even small changes in the sweetener make a huge difference. I make a wintry dark rum version of this with El Dorado 8 and Demerara gum syrup that is just delicious.

Expand full comment

New here, so I'm catching up on old posts, but as a rum aficianado, I have to say I'm curious about there being no mention of El Floridita, Hemingway and Havana. Am I wrong about the daquiri's origin story? My understanding is also that Hemingway hated sweet drinks, and in replicating the original, Luxardo stands in for syrup. Much drier ... and better, imo. Finally, my go-to daquiri rum is the Havana Club Anejo Blanco (Puerto Rican), which is several levels above Bacardi for a $20 bottle.

Expand full comment

Really like this daiquiri recipe, FWIW.

Expand full comment

Maybe you’ve covered this elsewhere (I apologize if so) but is there a particular type of lime one should be using for juicing?

Expand full comment

There are folks who are obsessed with the providence and seasonality of their fruit. I am not one of them. I literally just purchase bags of whatever ordinary limes Trader Joe’s is selling.

The only exception to this is that very occasionally I specifically purchase key limes, which are much smaller and kind of a pain to juice, but are specifically called for in some recipes.

Freshness, origin, and seasonality obviously can make a difference. But in most cases it’s probably more effort than it’s worth to be too obsessed with that stuff at home.

Expand full comment

We made this last night with Plantation 3 Stars and Demerara syrup (as that's what we had on hand) and it was amazing. I'll have to try it with rich simple for comparison.

Expand full comment