11 Comments
User's avatar
Daniel Fernandes's avatar

I have a Dolin Red to finish, but the idea of Laphroaig in the back seat was brilliant. Added some Mission Fig & Fennel Bitters from Dashfire post-stir because I forgot the Angostura. This is a way more complex drink than I would have initially guessed at first glance. Now I'm wondering about putting some sherry in the drivers seat....

Expand full comment
Peter Suderman's avatar

Ooooh. I have not tried much in terms of Scotch/sherry combs. But I bet there’s a great Islay-PX sherry drink out there, waiting to be made.

Expand full comment
BB's avatar

Could I use another peaty scotch like Laphroaig or Lagavulin?

Expand full comment
Peter Suderman's avatar

Yes. Will definitely work, similar effect, it’s just that Ardbeg works especially well.

Expand full comment
Jake Y's avatar

Sorry, slightly off topic but we’re on a whole scotch thing now—should I buy drambouie? Is it more than just scotch and honey?

Expand full comment
Peter Suderman's avatar

https://cocktailswithsuderman.substack.com/p/the-cocktail-that-changed-my-mind

You should buy it just for the Kingston Club! Next week’s drink will have a bit of Laphroaig, but I think that will be all the Scotch planned for the next several months.

Expand full comment
Joe Colucci's avatar

My favorite original cocktail, featuring Ardbeg 10:

1 oz Ardbeg 10

1oz Laird's apple brandy

3/4 oz honeycrisp cider syrup (1:1 cider and demerara sugar)

1/2 oz St George Spiced Pear liqueur

2 dashes Angostura

Shake or stir, serve up

Expand full comment
Matt's avatar

Enjoying the reverse Rob Roy on porch tonight.

Expand full comment
Chris Ryley's avatar

I’m now tasting the Reverse Rob Roy made with Cynar (can’t get Punt e Mes here in Alberta). Hmm. Haven’t tasted the Ardbeg 10 on its own yet, but I’m definitely picking up on its gnarliness, even though is is being tempered with the Cynar. I think I’ll next have to try the Ardbeg neat or with a touch of water to explore it.

Thanks for pushing me past my comfort zone.

Expand full comment
Chris Ryley's avatar

Hmm. My wife tasted the Reverse Rob Roy and then the Ardbeg 10 neat, and said she prefers the scotch over the cocktail. The bitterness of the Cynar seems enhanced by the Ardbeg. Good news is that I like the scotch. Not too gnarly for me. I’ll need to try some different ‘vermouths’ to see if I can find a balance I like.

Expand full comment
André's avatar

Didn't have the Punt e Mes, so replaced it with a combination of Ramazotti for the bitterness and Antica Formula for sweetness and richness. Worked a treat, brilliant drink!

Expand full comment