31 Comments
Nov 22, 2022Liked by Peter Suderman

Can't wait to try it! Can you tell us the name of the well-stocked liquor store near you? I'm stuck with whatever Virginia ABC has in stock, and I'm trying to find more variety by venturing into DC.

Expand full comment
author

Batch 13 on 14th street: https://batch13wines.com/

It's a bit chaotic, but it supplies a lot of my more obscure ingredients.

I also order from Sherry's in Adams Morgan sometimes. https://www.sherryswine.com/spirits/

Expand full comment
Nov 23, 2022Liked by Peter Suderman

They have it at Schneider’s by the train station too—convenient stop if you’re picking people up there. Anyway I have all this stuff🤩 So excited! Gonna make one right now! My pecan bitters is El Guapo with chicory mixed in. I feel like this would be a good use for brown butter-washed bourbon—I might try that too later in the week. Happy Thanksgiving!

Expand full comment
author

My bottle of El Guapo Pecan/Chicory arrived today, so I haven't tried it yet, but I will be interested to see how it turns out.

Expand full comment
Nov 22, 2022Liked by Peter Suderman

Thanks...and Happy Thanksgiving!

Expand full comment
Nov 22, 2022Liked by Peter Suderman

I too felt limited by ABC's paltry selection of booze, but recently realized that you can order liquor from out of state online and have it delivered to your door in VA. In my case, I used a site called minibar and paid 25 bucks shipping for 7 bottles. There may be better deals out there, but I'd suggest checking it out if you don't feel like venturing into the city

Expand full comment
Nov 22, 2022Liked by Peter Suderman

Thanks for the tip. I haven't checked out minibar, but I had good luck with Astor Wines and Spirits. Free shipping on your first big order, but they don't deliver to VA, so I had to find a booze mule in DC. :)

Expand full comment
author

Astor is great. I live in DC, so I can get stuff sent to my doorstep. Shipping for a bottle or two tends to start high but the per-bottle increase is modest, so I tend to order 6-8 bottles at a time.

Expand full comment
Dec 1, 2022Liked by Peter Suderman

If you're in the Bay Area, Bitters & Bottles in South San Francisco & Umami Mart in Oakland both carry Miracle Mile bitters. Last time I was at Bitters & Bottles to buy the Xocolatl Mole bitters previously recommended, they did have Bittermen's brand in stock, but the storekeeper also recommended Miracle Mile's Chili & Chocolate which I have been using.

Expand full comment
author

That MM Chili and Chocolate is surprisingly great for something that sounds like a one-off weird ingredient.

Expand full comment
Dec 1, 2022Liked by Peter Suderman

One more thing, I've been trying Ms Better Bitters Miraculous Foamer as an egg white substitute, it seems to work great, but if you get a chance to try it, I'd like to hear your review.

Expand full comment
Nov 29, 2022Liked by Peter Suderman

Wow. The pecan pie flip was a smashing success at our Thanksgiving dinner - I was busy making flips for the guests right until we sat down to dinner. So busy that I didn’t get to make one for myself.

Much later, when all the guests were gone I finally made one for myself. It was really good… however inspiration struck and I subsequently added 5 drops of Fee Brothers Aztec Chocolate bitters. This took the drink from “really good” to “awesome!” (My opinion of course.)

Expand full comment
author

Oooh. I was so focused on the core Pecan Pie elements I didn’t even think to augment it.

Glad it worked for you and your guests!

Expand full comment
Nov 24, 2022Liked by Peter Suderman

I just got to the “remove any remaining solids” step in the pecan pie syrup prep, and man oh man was that some tasty residue. I wish I had had a freshly baked brownie to have drizzled it atop. MUSEUM DOCENT: “…and the native Americans made sure not to waste a single part of the bison.” ME: •cracks knuckles with a self-satisfied smirk and nod•

Expand full comment
Nov 24, 2022Liked by Peter Suderman

Great timing! I just got a bottle of the toasted pecan bitters a couple weeks ago, so I'll be able to try both.

Expand full comment
author

Oh, great! The Toasted Pecan Bitters are very good but also very specific. They really, really capture ... toasted pecans.

Expand full comment

Always room for another niche bitters in my collection. I got the toasted pecan bitters was to make an interesting old fashioned variant with cacao-infused Ramazzotti that I found in the Cocktail Codex.

Expand full comment
Nov 23, 2022Liked by Peter Suderman

The pecan pie syrup is, basically, orgeat! Nuts, sugar, water (and an aromatic), blended and strained.

This works with most any nut. And if you keep the brix close to 50, you can use them in recipe templates that call for simple syrup on a 1:1 basis. (Or rich simple, if, like this recipe, it's around 67 brix.)

Expand full comment
author

Yes. Exactly. I typically work with 66-67 brix syrups (2:1). This is sliiiiightly off, because of the nuts. But you can treat it like a nutty 2:1 syrup.

Expand full comment
Nov 23, 2022Liked by Peter Suderman

Does the pecan pie syrup work well in the old fashioned too?

Expand full comment
Nov 23, 2022Liked by Peter Suderman

The nut oils and solids in the syrup will make the drink a little cloudy. If you use rough-chopped pecans, and steep them in the syrup while hot (without blending), then strain, you might get a more clear syrup that would make the old fashioned look nicer.

Expand full comment
author

Yes, exactly right, although straining out the pecans before blending will leave you with a syrup that is less thick and nut-fatty, for lack of a better term. This particular syrup was designed to be heavy to give a bit of thickness to a flip.

Expand full comment
author

What Curious Task said. The answer is yes. I've done this. It tastes good! It's definitely cloudy, though.

Expand full comment

Thanks! I tried it last night and liked it a lot! (I stuck with your recipe instead of straining out the pecans because I cared more about the pecan flavor than having a clear drink.)

Expand full comment
Nov 22, 2022Liked by Peter Suderman

I'm tempted to add this to my already constructed Thanksgiving Cocktail menu - but I'm likely the only one that will drink a flip.

Expand full comment
author

Make the flip for dessert, not pre-dinner. Once you make one for one person, even if just yourself, you will make one for (almost) everyone.

(Invest in eggs.)

Non-cocktail people are sometimes scared of these raw egg drinks, which, fair.

But they are some of the most accessible drinks in all of cocktail-dom. If you like cake, you'll like a flip. And the "show" of dropping a whole raw egg into a shaker will entice people, especially once they see the eggy, frothy, sweet-thick result.

Expand full comment
author

Also I'm just stoked you're making a menu.

Expand full comment

I've only "invented" one cocktail, but it has become a standard at my family Christmas celebrations now. I always roast a duck for Christmas, and I decided the tastes that go into my roast duck would make a good cocktail. I stuff the duck with orange quarters, garlic, and rosemary, then make an orange sauce with Grand Marnier, orange juice, and orange zest. I didn't think garlic would work in a cocktail, so if left it out. Otherwise I made a rosemary syrup with a cup of water, a half cup of sugar, and a half cup of fresh rosemary leaves pressed down. I brought everything to a boil, let it sit until it was room temperature, and filtered it. To make the cocktail, I combine a shot of bourbon, a tablespoon of Grand Marnier, a tablespoon of rosemary syrup, and a splash of club soda in an old fashioned glass. My whole family and I love it.

Expand full comment

My syrup was too much vanilla and not enough nuts. I wonder if I didn't toast them long enough (I did not want to burn them!). I think I'll try different amounts of each tomorrow morning.

Expand full comment

Have you tried making a cocktail with it yet? I felt the same when I tasted my syrup, but in a drink I liked it more.

Expand full comment

Yes I made the flip and liked it. The vanilla wasn't overpowering in the drink, but I still didn't get enough pecan. Maybe its my unsophisticated palate.

Expand full comment